The Crowhill Report - Content

Views and opinions on the news, culture, politics, beer, art, science, education, religion and ethics

Sites endorsed by Crowhill:
Crowhill Publishing
The Krehbiel Report on Publishing@gregkrehbiel

The internet that cried “me too”?

by Greg Krehbiel on 16 October 2017

People have taken to posting “me too” on their Facebook pages so the rest of us can see how widespread a problem we have. This latest social media outrage was allegedly inspired from a tweet by Alyssa Milano.

“If all the women and men who have been sexually harassed, assaulted or abused wrote ‘me too’ as a status, we might give people a sense of the magnitude of the problem. #metoo”

Maybe. But it seems to me that “harassed, assaulted or abused” is too broad a criterion.

I’m not in favor of people being subjected to any of these things, but “sexually harassed” has become such a loose term, I would have a hard time imagining anyone — man or woman — who hasn’t been subjected to it. And when you universalize an issue like that, it might have the opposite of the intended effect.

In other words, you see that your friend posts “me too” on their Facebook page, and you can’t help but thinking, “Okay, I know I’m supposed to reply with some sort of cry-face emoji, but the ‘barrier to entry’ is so low, it might mean no more than that somebody called you Toots.”

5 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-16  ::  Greg Krehbiel

Does universal healthcare stifle innovation?

by Greg Krehbiel on 16 October 2017

This is a thought experiment. I don’t know how this sort of thing plays out in the real world.

Imagine there’s some disease called mancer. It kills 10,000 people a year, and there’s no effective treatment.

Now imagine a doctor comes up with a treatment, but the treatment costs $20 million.

Scenario 1 — No universal health care.

A couple rich people (or their children) get mancer. They gladly pay the $20 million to get the treatment. Through that process they learn how to bring the cost down so it’s only $5 million, which puts the treatment in the range of more people, which allows for continued innovation to drive the price down. Eventually it’s cheap enough that the 10,000 people a year can get it.

Scenario 2 — Universal health care.

There’s no way the country can afford to spend $20 million on 10,000 people each year, so the treatment goes nowhere.

I have a sneaking suspicion something like this is how healthcare actually works. The United States develops all sorts of innovative drugs and therapies, and countries with socialized medicine get the benefit. If the United States goes to socialized medicine, will that be the end of innovation?

7 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-16  ::  Greg Krehbiel

“Gender stereotypes” saved lives in Louisiana

by Greg Krehbiel on 13 October 2017

Pigweed sent along this link: Gender stereotypes are destroying girls, and they’re killing boys

You know the drill. “Toxic masculinity.” The worst thing you can tell a boy is to be a man. Blah blah blah.

When the Cajun Navy hooked up their bass boats, drove 400 miles and went house to house to rescue people from flood waters, why doesn’t “masculinity” get any credit?

When that guy carried a mother and daughter out of harm’s way, why don’t “gender stereotypes” get some credit?

Yes, I know there are female first responders and such, but by and large it’s a man’s business.

Thank God they were raised to be men!

6 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-13  ::  Greg Krehbiel


by Greg Krehbiel on 13 October 2017

I am, often unfortunately, a Washington Redskins fan. So this morning when I saw a man wearing a burgundy and gold #17 jersey, I knew that was the number worn by both Billy Kilmer and Doug Williams, who led the Redskins to win Super Bowl XXII. (Are you allowed to say Super Bowl 22, or is that a trademark violation?) That season, Williams was the only starting black quarterback in the NFL, and he was the first black quarterback to win a Super Bowl.

The Redskins didn’t just win that Super Bowl. It was a rout. Williams was incredible, throwing four touchdowns in a single quarter.

His next season wasn’t so good, and the season after that he lost the starting job to Mark Rypien.

A lot of people saw racism in Williams’ rapid decline, and Williams fed that with his book, Quarterblack. (Which I haven’t read, but I just ordered it.)

I have no idea if racism played into the demise of his career, and that’s not my point.

There are lots of potential explanations for why Williams lost the starting position, despite his stunning performance in SB22. The most obvious is that he wasn’t playing as well, but there could be others. Maybe he was making himself a pain, either to management or the other players. Maybe there was a contract dispute.

I don’t know, and I don’t follow that side of football. I like the games, but I don’t get into all the behind-the-scenes stuff.

What’s interesting to me is the way some people react to this story. They assume the answer is racism, and not only that, they then use it as an example of racism.

IOW, they read racism into the situation, and that conclusion bolsters their conviction that racism is rampant.

I’m not saying race had nothing to do with it. It’s possible there is very good reason to believe that race had almost everything to do with it. I’m leaving open the possibility that some people say it’s an example of racism because it actually was. I was alive and aware back then, and there was a lot of racism. People may have solid reasons to believe Williams was a victim of it.

There may be such people, but living in the D.C. area I’ve heard lots and lots of people use Doug Williams as an example of racism in the NFL, and I can guarantee you that most of them do not have solid reasons. They had a suspicion, which became a belief, which became a “fact” in support of that belief.

Confirmation bias. We all do it.

We’re inclined to see something a certain way, and then the very act of seeing it that way feeds our bias.

2 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-13  ::  Greg Krehbiel

The end of the Boy Scouts?

by Greg Krehbiel on 12 October 2017

The Boy Scouts (sic) has decided to admit girls. Is that only girls who identify as boys, or ….

I was only a Boy Scout for a short time, and I’m no expert, but this seems like their death spiral just entered into a sharp downward phase.

Boys don’t want to be in a club with girls. That’s called school.

7 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-12  ::  Greg Krehbiel

“Blaming the victim”

by Greg Krehbiel on 10 October 2017

If some powerful man is harassing women at work, or women who are looking for career advancement, or deals, or whatever it is, and he’s trading sex for favors, then I think most people can agree that he’s in the wrong.

To what extent do the women who gain such favors share in the blame? Calling them “victims” might be a stretch in some cases. They got what they wanted out of the deal — often, as I understand it, they got quite a bit out of the deal. At least to some extent they’re perpetuating the arrangement.

So, for example, in the Weinstein case, should the women who got what they wanted from Mr. Weistein be exposed?

I’m not saying they’re as guilty as Weinstein. But do they share some of the blame?

39 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-10  ::  Greg Krehbiel

Economics for non-rational actors?

by Greg Krehbiel on 10 October 2017

I haven’t read too much about this, so consider this a top of mind comment.

Based on some things I’ve skimmed the last few days, Richard Thaler just won the Nobel Prize for his work showing that people are far from the “rational actors” they are (allegedly) assumed to be in standard economics.

I’ve read a fair bit about how irrational people can be in the context of persuasion. Especially sales and marketing. E.g., there are words and colors and phrases that work better than others.

For example, you probably remember when TV sales pitches for a new product had a line like, “operators are standing by.” Somebody realized that creates a mental image of idle operators who aren’t doing anything because nobody is calling to get the silly product. They changed it to “if it’s busy, please call again,” and results were much better.

Is that the future of “economics”? What’s the best way to trick people into buying things?

13 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-10  ::  Greg Krehbiel

Even a brief respite …

by Greg Krehbiel on 10 October 2017

… can break you of bad habits.

I took a short (2-day) backpacking trip this past weekend with my daughter. I came back with a very different perspective on all the silly things that normally engage my mind.

What are some other ways you find helpful to get out of your own head? Here are some ideas. Please add yours.

  • Prayer (especially with written prayers, like the Psalms).
  • Reading a book that’s very different from what you usually read.
  • Working with your hands.
  • Organizing a messy room.

5 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-10  ::  Greg Krehbiel

Those evil Democrats

by Greg Krehbiel on 5 October 2017

More than 50 people killed, and more than 500 wounded, and they have the raw nerve to suggest that maybe we should do something about it!

The problem, of course, is that most of the proposed “solutions” aren’t solutions at all. (How would getting rid of silencers change anything?)

What we need is an honest airing of the issues. Not Wayne LaPierre yelling at Kirsten Gillibrand, “moderated” by some entertainment personality masquerading as a journalist.

We need something like Firing Line, where the real issues can be discussed. And I think we need to take the cameras, the microphones and the reporters out of Senate hearings so “the world’s greatest deliberative body” can deliberate, rather than pose.

Maybe the entire Congress needs to go on a private retreat for one month out of the year.

We’ve become way too Democratic. Public temper tantrums and social media outrage has far too much influence on the way we run this country. We need a way to take a step back, take a deep breath, and think about things — without the fear of being called ridiculous names.

3 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-05  ::  Greg Krehbiel

Picking on Facebook

by Greg Krehbiel on 3 October 2017

You might like this: Is Facebook a media company, and why does it matter?

6 comments  ::  Add your comment  ::  2017-10-03  ::  Greg Krehbiel

2017-10-03 :: Greg Krehbiel // General
Paglia on Hefner
2017-09-28 :: Greg Krehbiel // General
Okay, solar energy, do your thing
+ 1 comment
2017-09-28 :: Greg Krehbiel // General
Governor Hogan, no more toll roads!
2017-09-28 :: Greg Krehbiel // General
“Trump does not do diplomatic-speak”